Media Cell, Naga Club
The book on the history of the Naga Club that was released yesterday is not an individual's personal interpretation or opinion. It was officially and properly examined, discussed and approved repeatedly by all the Office Bearers, Advisors and Executive Members before publication.
However, the claim that the Europe Returnees formed the Naga Club in October 1918 does not stand up to historical scrutiny. There are several important reasons why this claim must be questioned.
1. The leadership of Rheichalie Pienyü: If the Europe Returnees were indeed the founders or co-founders of the Naga Club in 1918, why was Rheichalie Pienyü compelled to shoulder the responsibilities of President, Secretary and Treasurer of the Naga Club for 24 years, beginning on 7 January 1918?
Had the Europe Returnees been among the founders or co-founders, one would reasonably expect at least some of them to have held positions such as General Secretary, Secretary, Joint Secretary, Vice-President, Treasurer or Vice-Treasurer.
Such appointments would have provided tangible historical evidence of their involvement in the founding leadership of the Naga Club.
We have absolutely no intention of excluding anyone who genuinely contributed to the formation and development of the Naga Club. However, historical truth must be revealed, established and upheld for posterity. Our coming generations must be able to stand on the foundation of truth and reject historical claims that cannot be substantiated by evidence.
It is also important to understand that educated and capable manpower was extremely limited in those days, despite Rheichalie Pienyü's efforts to promote and encourage educated people to participate in the affairs of the Club.
2. The inspiration behind the formation of the Naga Club: The Naga Club was formed by the DC staff at Kohima, who were deeply and profoundly inspired by the British Clubs operating in Nagaland. These British Clubs played a significant role in fostering strong unity, collective identity and an unwavering spirit of nationalism among British officers. Through regular discussions and deliberations on current affairs, developments and challenges, they were able to formulate collective positions and united responses to the circumstances of their time.
The DC staff at Kohima were inspired by this culture of unity and collective responsibility and sought to establish a similar institution for the Nagas.
3. The Naga Club initially functioned as a free guest house: The Naga Club was initially established as a free guest house constructed below the Mission Compound at Kohima. Its purpose went beyond providing free accommodation and other utilities. It was a visionary initiative intended to promote Naga brotherhood, unity, a spirit of Naga nationalism and the concept of a Naga nation founded on a collective identity.
However, there is no known historical evidence connecting the Europe Returnees with the establishment or initial operation of this free guest house below Mission Compound. If anyone possesses documentary evidence or reliable historical records establishing such a connection, they are welcome to share them for public examination and consultation so that this historical question can be resolved conclusively.
4. Financial contributions made by the DC staff: To finance this noble and visionary initiative of providing free accommodation, every member of the DC staff at Kohima willingly contributed four annas or two annas, according to their grades and positions in government service.
This collective financial contribution demonstrates the commitment and willingness of the DC staff to establish and sustain an institution that would serve the wider Naga community.
However, there is no known historical document or evidence demonstrating that the Europe Returnees, excluding those serving in the DC's office, took part in this particular financial contribution towards establishing the free guest house that initially functioned as the Naga Club.
If at all there exists evidence of such financial contributions, it should be brought forward for public examination.
5. The four Europe Returnees who signed the Simon Commission memorandum: There were four Europe Returnees associated with the signing of the memorandum submitted to the Simon Commission: Dr Khosa Angami, a resident of Kohima; Apamo Lotha; Luzevi Sema; Nikhriehu Angami.
Dr Khosa Angami was the only one among the four who did not serve in the DC's office at Kohima. He was a resident of Kohima, whereas the other three served in the DC's office.
This distinction is important when examining the historical circumstances surrounding the formation of the Naga Club.
The fact that three of these Europe Returnees served in the DC's office does not, by themselves, establish that they took the initiative or assumed the leadership in forming the Naga Club. There must be documentary evidence establishing their specific roles in the Club's original formation. Their subsequent contributions to Naga political affairs should not automatically be treated as proof of their status as the founders.
6. The chronological gap between the formation of the Naga Club and the Simon Commission: The Naga Club was formed on 7 January 1918, whereas the memorandum to the Simon Commission was submitted in 1929. There is therefore a considerable chronological gap between these two historical events. More importantly, there is no publicly established historical evidence demonstrating that the Europe Returnees exercised founding leadership in the Naga Club or its original free guest house during the period from 1918 to 1928. Their involvement in the 1929 Simon Commission memorandum cannot, on its own, be used as evidence that they were initial founders of the Naga Club in 1918. Historical events must be examined in their proper chronological context, and later contributions must not be confused with the original establishment of an institution.
7. The rejection of the earlier account of Naga Club history: The earlier account of Naga Club history, reportedly prepared by some highly knowledgeable individuals, was rejected approximately 25 years ago because it included the claim that one of the Europe Returnees was also among the founders of the Naga Club. That particular claim was subsequently challenged and considered unsubstantiated.
Therefore, it is necessary to understand why the same claim is being advanced again without producing convincing historical documentation. Historical narratives should not be repeatedly revived merely because they have appeared in earlier unauthorized publications by a few individuals. They must stand on reliable records, documentary evidence and verifiable facts.
8. Contributions and founding status are two different matters: The Europe Returnees may have contributed significantly to the development of the Naga Club in the subsequent years since its inception as well as to the wider Naga political movement. Their contributions, wherever established by historical evidence, should be duly recognised and appreciated.
However, acknowledging their contributions is entirely different from accepting the claim that they were founders or co-founders of the Naga Club. The two matters must not be confused. There are several other historical reasons why the Europe Returnees were not recognised as founders in the account presented by the Naga Club. If this controversy continues, perhaps, the most constructive way forward would be to organise an open public discussion, that may even be livestreamed, involving knowledgeable historians, former office bearers and present office bearers of the Naga Club, researchers and individuals who hold differing views giving everyone an equal opportunity to present documentary evidence, explain their historical understanding and respond to questions. The ultimate objective should not be to defend individuals or promote competing narratives, but to establish the historical truth for posterity.