Understanding the Naga Situation

Ngaranmi Shimray 
New Delhi

The formation of the Naga Club in 1918 inspired the Nagas to envision a Naga Nation. This aspiration was conveyed to the Simon Commission, urging the British, when they departed from independent India, to leave the Nagas alone as they had lived since time immemorial. A.Z. Phizo later translated this yearning into a movement for an independent Naga country, leading to a plebiscite and thereafter a declaration of Naga independence in 1947. Armed struggle ensued, with independent India deploying its armed forces to brutally suppress the movement. Opportunities for a peaceful settlement with Phizo were lost, as he demanded nothing less than full sovereignty. The Naga forefathers laid the foundation for a Naga Nation, and the struggle toward that goal belongs to every Naga tribe, wherever they are situated, and not to any tribe in particular.

The intransigence of the NNC hawks saw the emergence of moderates who worked out a plan to create a separate state for the Nagas, thereby weakening the broader freedom movement. Hailing mainly from the Naga Hills Tuensang Area, then part of Assam, these moderates did not seriously consider other Naga-inhabited areas for inclusion in their scheme specified in the 16-Point Memorandum. As a result, members of the same Naga tribes find themselves today living beyond the borders of Nagaland. The outcome of the 16-Point Agreement indicates a lack of understanding of the Naga geography of that era, which was largely dictated by colonial administrative boundaries. This has led many Nagas to conclude that the moderates were in a hurry to wrap up the deal, content with creating a political entity within the Union of India regardless of its small landmass and incomplete coverage of Naga tribes.

The immediate beneficiaries of the new state became the ruling class, developing a vested interest in collaborating with New Delhi to retain their political ascendancy. Students of modern Indian history will recall how the zamindars empowered by British colonial rulers became a loyal middle class to protect their own power. Similarly, vested interests are emerging among the Nagas today who seek to protect their political turf by peddling narratives that could sabotage a peaceful resolution to the Naga political issue.

The creation of Nagaland threw up two major problems: first, the NNC rejected the deal and continued its armed struggle for sovereignty; second, the agreement left out a sizeable Naga population living in adjacent areas, who subsequently threw their support behind the NNC. Although there have been a few interim peace agreements and changes in leadership and organisations over the decades, these shifts have never dampened the Naga spirit of striving to be a free people.

Recognising the shifting realities at home and around the globe, a ceasefire was declared jointly by the Government of India and NSCN in 1997 to resolve the Naga political issue through dialogue. Painstakingly long negotiations culminated in the Framework Agreement (FA) of August 2015, which rested on the core principle that a final settlement would be anchored in the "unique history" of the Nagas and a mutual appreciation of both parties' situations. However, before the fine print could be finalised, the momentum for peace was derailed when the ruling NDA government returned with a larger parliamentary majority and fulfilled its manifesto promise to abrogate Article 370, which had granted Jammu and Kashmir its own flag and constitution.

This development ran counter to what the Framework Agreement was understood to permit for the Nagas, a Naga Flag and Constitution. As time passed, it became apparent that New Delhi was reluctant to honour this aspect of the understanding. Naga negotiators have stated unequivocally that without these two demands, there can be no settlement. Since the FA was signed in the presence of the Prime Minister of India, it raised high hopes for a lasting Naga Peace Accord. While Article 370 applied to J&K, Article 371A applies to Nagaland. The Naga Flag and Constitution are core elements without which a final deal cannot be signed. Since the FA officially recognised the unique history of the Nagas, accommodating a Naga Flag and Constitution under Article 371A is both logical and feasible. Against this backdrop, it is only fair and incumbent upon the Government of India to honour the spirit of the agreement. Unlike the J&K issue, the Naga issue does not pose a threat to India's security.

Nagas are known for their loyalty and honour, and they will ensure that the country’s eastern border remains secure. Under an honourable arrangement, the Nagas will stand as fierce defenders of their land along the eastern frontier, transforming into a vital strategic asset for the country.

Many Nagas believe that the compulsions of the past, when moderates snapped up statehood within the Indian Constitution, derailed the chance for meaningful peace talks between the hawks and New Delhi, a misstep in haste that can now be remedied through the ongoing negotiations. The 1997 ceasefire and the 2015 Framework Agreement revived hope that a Naga Flag and Constitution, among other provisions, would form the bedrock of "shared sovereignty", a concept viewed as honourable in the eyes of the Nagas. Furthermore, the Naga negotiators have made a major concession in the competencies by agreeing to postpone territorial integration to a future date, while proposing clear interim arrangements. Three decades of negotiations have not been wasted; rather, they have yielded a mature understanding of the complexities facing both sides, as reflected in the proposed competencies.

Even though a Naga Flag and Constitution were not explicitly named in the text of the FA, it was clearly understood from numerous peace talks that recognising the unique history of the Nagas implied granting both. Article 370 has no bearing on the Nagas, and their demands should be enabled under Article 371A. Moreover, the integration of all Naga-inhabited areas into Nagaland, whose permissibility was acknowledged in Point 13 of the 16-Point Agreement, is a natural corollary of recognising unique Naga history and, in the interest of securing a peace deal, it has been deferred for a more opportune time. Having committed to a peaceful resolution across the negotiating table, it is now up to New Delhi to facilitate these aspirations. Most of the demands can be accommodated through targeted constitutional amendments: Article 371A (for the Naga Flag, Constitution, and cross-border trade), Article 244(2) (for the NRTC and Autonomous District Councils with enhanced powers), Article 371C (granting hill areas rights over their resources), and statutory recognition for the Naga Hoho in line with its mandate.

The Nagas have waited patiently since 1997. Having signed the Framework Agreement, the parties must not delay the fulfilment of this commitment to finally resolve the Naga political issue.

 



Support The Morung Express.
Your Contributions Matter
Click Here