Mushrooming of Unproductive Unions and Associations in Nagaland

N Kampong Konyak 
Aboiyang Ward, Aboi Town

Nagaland is witnessing the growth of unproductive unions and associations. This trend is adversely affecting the State on multiple fronts.

There are number of individuals, both educated and uneducated, who appear reluctant to contribute to the State's economy through productive works. However, they are relentlessly engaged in forming unions and associations, perhaps as a means of maintaining their status and influence in the society.

It is ridiculous that some genuinely believe that they are working for society simply because they hold positions in unions or associations. They usually have a notion that the Union is a society in itself and mislead the general public of the same. In reality, some of these organisations end up doing more harm than good through forced donations, coercive practices and the unnecessary activities that consume valuable time and resources without producing any positive outcome.

Over time, some office bearers begin to assume that they can issue orders and directives to members or general public at their own whims and fancies. This is a misplaced sense of authority. Members do not surrender their individual rights upon joining a union. Unless the constitution of the organisation which is drafted and accepted by its members empowers them, office bearers have no authority to impose or dictate terms to others. Even where such powers are provided, they must function within the frameworks of the organisation's mandate.

On numerous occasions, attempts are being made to draw parallels with the State. However, the two are fundamentally different in all fronts.

The State derives its authority from the Constitution which is drafted by the representatives of the people and it draws its authority from the consent of the governed. The relation between the state and the citizens can be understood through the concept of a social contract, whereby citizens accept the constitutional framework, discharge their civic responsibilities and pay taxes, while the State, in return, is responsible for protecting the lives and properties of citizens, maintaining law and order, providing essential public services and ensuring the overall welfare of society.

A union or association, on the other hand, derives its authority primarily from the consent of its members. It cannot assume the authority to issue directives or curtail the rights of its members.

Despite Nagaland being a State for more than six decades, it continues to depend heavily on grants and financial assistance from the Central Government. This raises serious questions about our collective responsibility towards the growth of our State.

Instead of focusing on productive activities, entrepreneurship, employment generation and economic development, we increasingly find people investing their time and energy in forming multiple unions and associations, often with overlapping objectives and little contribution to the growth of our society.

Institutions such as Village Councils and Tribal Hohos/Unions are exceptional institutions in the State that have been delegated with specific roles and responsibilities pertaining to Naga customary laws and social practices under the Nagaland Village and Tribal Councils Act, 1978. This special recognition is the acknowledgement of the fact that Nagaland is a tribal State with distinct customary and social practices that require protection. Their authority and legitimacy, therefore, arise not merely from the voluntary coming together of individuals but also from their recognised institutional and customary roles within Naga society.

On the contrary, we often see many NGOs and unions with no delegated powers that tend to venture into areas beyond their jurisdiction, only to find themselves unable to enforce their own resolutions. One such instance is the resolutions passed by various organisations and unions seeking to prohibit parents from sending their children to work as domestic helpers. While the intention behind such resolutions may be commendable, enforcing them becomes challenging in the absence of a statutory provision. Good intentions alone are not enough.

We must therefore understand the objective of forming a union or association. It is generally established when individuals with common interests voluntarily come together to promote their welfare and work towards common goals. It is not established to empower office bearers to dictate terms, issue arbitrary orders to participate in activities against their will.

A union is not society in itself. It is merely one component of the larger society in which we live. It cannot claim a monopoly over the interests or collective conscience of the people.

The greatest contribution one can make to society is to work honestly, sincerely and diligently in whatever profession, assignment or responsibility one undertakes. For instance, if you are a student, your greatest contribution to society at this stage is to study sincerely and equip yourself with knowledge and skills. By doing this, you become a competent doctor who contributes towards better healthcare services, you become a good teacher who helps to educate future generations, you become a capable public servant who strengthens public institutions, you become a visionary politician who helps formulate sound policies and take the State forward.

A society cannot progress without good road connectivity, quality healthcare, competent teachers, good schools and colleges, productive agriculture, entrepreneurship and a sustainable economy. These are the foundations for the advancement of society. Unions and associations, by themselves, will not build roads, operate hospitals, improve educational institutions or generate economic opportunities. These essential responsibilities require competent individuals in the institutions.

This is not to undermine the important role played by unions and NGOs as watchdogs. Their contributions to community welfare and the protection of people's rights are commendable.

It is time we ponder whether the path we are currently taking is sustainable in the long run. A society cannot progress merely through rhetoric, or the pursuit of influence and recognition. True progress comes from productive contributions and tangible development that improve the lives of people from all walks of life.



Support The Morung Express.
Your Contributions Matter
Click Here