Issued by Rali Wali, NNC/FGN
Under the leadership of Zhopra Vero
The NNC/FGN reiterates that the historical and political aspiration of the Naga people has always been self-determination. This aspiration was unequivocally articulated in the memorandum submitted by the Naga Club to the Simon Commission in 1929, reaffirmed through the declaration of Naga Independence on 14 August 1947, and further demonstrated through the 1951 Naga Voluntary Plebiscite. These historic milestones established the political position of the Naga people under the banner of the Naga National Council.
From 1929 until the mid-1950s, the political aspiration of the Naga people remained fundamentally consistent: self-determination and nothing less. However, following India's failure to suppress the Naga national movement through military force, a different political strategy began to emerge. Through political manoeuvring, the exploitation of internal vulnerabilities and the enticement of certain elements within the NNC ranks, individuals who abandoned the original national aspiration collaborated with the Government of India in establishing the Naga People's Convention (NPC) in 1957. The subsequent Sixteen-Point Agreement and the creation of Nagaland State in 1963 institutionalised a political arrangement that neither originated from nor fulfilled the original demand for Naga self-determination.
The NNC/FGN believes that certain brainwashed sections of our people appear to have become increasingly oblivious to the fundamental reality that India and the Nagas are worlds apart. Whichever angle we examine it from, what common ground do we genuinely share? What cultural ties bind us? What historical connections unite us? Or what political foundations do we have in common with India? These are fundamental questions that demand honest reflection rather than convenient political interpretations.
Are the Nagas prepared to be remembered as a people who abandoned their history and political principles and embraced a deceptive political trajectory manufactured through an illegitimate marriage between opportunists and an imperialist Indian establishment? The uncomfortable truth is that we have grown increasingly accustomed to India's policy of appeasement, to the extent that historical truth, political conviction and the very values that define our identity appear to have become secondary, provided that unaccounted financial assistance and development packages continue to flow without accountability.
Statehood was never the political aspiration for which the Naga people declared their independence and made enormous sacrifices. An administrative arrangement brought about through deceptive political manoeuvring within the Indian Union cannot be equated with the recognition of our historical and political rights.
The NNC/FGN cautions the Nagas against being trapped into accepting the so-called state arrangement born out of illegitimate union as the fulfilment of Naga aspirations, an arrangement which, by and large, has failed in every discernible area of its expected functions. Furthermore, the Nagas must seriously ponder the presumed constitutional safeguards under Article 371A, upon which certain sections have come to rely excessively. Notwithstanding its special provisions, Article 371A remains an integral part of the Constitution of India and cannot be regarded as an independent guarantee of our historical and political rights. The experience of Jammu and Kashmir following the abrogation of Article 370 should serve as a reminder that constitutional protections remain subject to constitutional amendments and the political powers of the Indian State. We must, therefore, distinguish between administrative safeguards and the fundamental question of self-determination.
Furthermore, if we recall how Nagaland Affairs was transferred from the Ministry of External Affairs to the Ministry of Home Affairs in 1972, despite the formal opposition expressed through a resolution of the Nagaland Legislative Assembly on 29 June of that year, the implications become even more significant. Despite the Assembly's objections, the administrative transfer proceeded. This episode raises a fundamental question about the actual extent of Nagaland's political autonomy and the effectiveness of the constitutional safeguards upon which they have come to rely. Even the fate of point 12 and 13 of the 16-Point Agreement remains obscure, with no account of their implementation.
Today, the much-harped-about subject in the Naga homeland is undoubtedly a solution founded upon the two existing agreements, which deserve due attention and serious consideration. However, what we consciously or unconsciously tend to overlook is the historical record of agreements entered into between the Nagas and the Government of India. Whether it was the Nine-Point Agreement, the Sixteen-Point Agreement, the Shillong Accord or the two present agreements, the fundamental question of the Government of India's sincerity, credibility and commitment remains a matter of grave concern.
The Government of India has, time and again, demonstrated a recurring pattern of failing to honour the agreements it has signed with the Nagas. The historical record reveals a persistent discrepancy between commitments undertaken and their actual implementation. Indeed, of all the agreements concluded with the Government of India, there is not one, repeat, not one, that has been honoured in its true letter and spirit. This is not merely a question of political mistrust; it is a matter of historical experience that cannot conveniently be disregarded or consigned to oblivion.
Therefore, the pertinent question that demands serious introspection is this: Would it be prudent for the Nagas to enter into any future political agreement with the Government of India without the presence, oversight and guarantee of an internationally recognised body or a consortium of credible international institutions, vested with the authority to monitor compliance and exert diplomatic pressure to ensure that such an agreement is faithfully honoured and implemented in its entirety, both in letter and in spirit?
The NNC/FGN further maintains that the Naga political question cannot be reinterpreted by a handful of self-appointed leaders who have so deeply institutionalised their allegiance through decades of servitude to their political masters that they are simply parroting the same position advanced against the Naga aspiration by their master. One is left to wonder whether courage, conviction and political integrity find any place in their dictionary or whether these virtues have long been surrendered at the altar of political subservience. It expresses regret that certain individuals have been desperately attempting to segregate the shared Naga cause along tribalistic and southern-eastern lines. Such attempts are deliberately intended to undermine the unity and sense of Nagahood that our pioneers fought for and established through the platform of Naga nationalism.
The NNC/FGN hopes that the historical episodes of betrayal witnessed through the emergence of the NPCs will serve as a sobering lesson and will not be repeated. While one section of fellow Naga people remained steadfast in its pursuit of our national aspiration, another was led astray by political opportunism, personal interests, and collaboration with the adversary in search of greener pastures. Our shared cause must therefore be pursued in unity, anchored in our historical truth, strengthened by political conviction and sustained through mutual responsibility.
The NNC/FGN, therefore, calls upon all Nagas to rise above individual interests, tribal divisions and political opportunism, and to reaffirm the historical principles upon which the Naga national movement was founded. Our political future must not be bartered away for temporary benefits, financial assistance or positions of power.
Statehood is not self-determination, administrative concessions are not political rights, and financial assistance is no substitute for an honourable political settlement.
The Naga political question remains unfinished. Its resolution must be founded upon historical rights, genuine political recognition and the freely expressed will of the Naga people.
The political destiny of the Nagas belongs to the Naga people, and the responsibility to defend that destiny rests with us all.