Nagaland ASI case: Review petition filed at Gauhati HC Principal Seat

Matter listed for December 8

 

 

Morung Express News
Dimapur | November 20

In a fresh development in the Nagaland police recruitment case involving Assistant Sub-Inspectors (ASIs) and other ranks, a review petition has been moved before the Gauhati High Court's Principal Seat at Guwahati, following the dismissal of the affected personnel's writ appeal by the High Court and subsequent Special Leave Petition (SLP) by the Supreme Court.

A Division Bench comprising Justice Sanjay Kumar Medhi and Justice Anjan Moni Kalita, on November 17, condoned an 86-day delay in preferring the connected review petition and directed that it be numbered and listed on December 8.

The application filed by 31 personnel connected with the case. 

According to the order, counsel for the State and the private respondents submitted that they had no serious objections to condonation of the delay, but would raise their objections in the review petition.

Court records indicated that the applicants had initially filed an interlocutory application at the Kohima Bench on September 16, 2026. The proceeding was subsequently closed at Kohima on September 29 following an administrative transfer to the Principal Seat at Guwahati.

The Principal Seat's case status records proceedings on November 14 and November 17, with the latter resulting in the order condoning the delay.

The November 17 order, however, does not specify the grounds on which the review is sought.

Background 

The latest development follows the Gauhati High Court's October 30, 2025 judgment dismissing a writ appeal (WA/27/2024) against a Single Judge's September 26, 2024 ruling.

The original writ petition, WP(C)/317/2023, challenged appointments made during 2019–2020 to the posts of Sub-Inspector (SI), Unarmed Branch Sub-Inspector (UBSI), Assistant Sub-Inspector (ASI) and Instructor Havildar without public advertisement.

The Single Judge had quashed the appointments and directed the State Government to undertake fresh recruitment through public advertisement, in accordance with Articles 14 and 16 of the Constitution.

The affected personnel were permitted to participate in the fresh selection process with relaxation of the upper age limit, but without relaxation of basic qualifications or departmental physical fitness criteria.

The Single Judge had also permitted them to continue in service for six months or until fresh appointments were made, whichever was earlier.

In their appeal, the affected personnel argued that the appointments should be treated as irregular rather than illegal. They also contended that recruitment under the Nagaland Police Manual and the exigencies of police duties justified the absence of advertisement.

However, the Division Bench rejected these arguments, holding that public employment must provide fair and equal opportunity to eligible candidates.

It upheld the Single Judge's directions, dismissed the writ appeal and vacated the interim status quo order that had been operating during the appellate proceedings.

Supreme Court declines interference

The affected personnel subsequently filed an SLP in the Supreme Court. On May 22, 2026, a Bench comprising Justice Dipankar Datta and Justice Satish Chandra Sharma declined to interfere with the High Court's October 30, 2025 judgment and dismissed the SLP.

With the latest order, the affected personnel have returned to the High Court through the review process. However, the November 17 order concerns only condonation of delay and does not amount to reconsideration or modification of the earlier judgment.

The review petition is scheduled to be taken up on December 8.

It must be noted that a similar case concerning the recruitment of Nagaland Police constables was adjudicated by the High Court around the same time, with the court relying on the findings and directions in the constable recruitment matter while deciding the subsequent case involving SI, ASI and other posts. The State has since undertaken fresh recruitment of constables pursuant to the court’s directions. 


 



Support The Morung Express.
Your Contributions Matter
Click Here